Performance Studies offers a distinctive and broad approach to understanding human experience that dramatically expands the scope of inquiry beyond what is usually found in traditional humanities fields like theatre, literature, and history. At its core, Performance Studies redefines “performance” not just as an object of analysis, such as a play or a historical event, but as a fundamental method and a standard part of everyday life, providing unique ways for research and knowledge creation. This interdisciplinary field challenges traditional academic borders by combining diverse perspectives, from anthropology and sociology to critical race theory and feminist thought, to explore how meanings are enacted, embodied, and communicated. As we see in the introduction from Henry Bial, the editor of The Performance Studies Reader, states, “What makes performance studies unique is that it shares the characteristics of its object: performance. Just as performance is contingent, contested, hard to pin down, so too is its study.” This inherent uncertainty is seen as a strength, enabling ongoing exploration and adaptation. (Bial)
One of Performance Studies’ main contributions is its inclusive view of “performance,” which goes far beyond traditional staged plays or written texts. Richard Schechner, a leading figure in the field, calls for a “comprehensive overhaul of curricula” to include “the study of performance in ritual and social settings.” He emphasizes that “performance—distinct from subgenres such as theatre, dance, music, and performance art—is a broad range of activities, including performing arts, rituals, healing practices, sports, popular entertainment, and everyday performances.” This perspective facilitates a comprehensive analysis of a diverse array of phenomena, including everyday greetings, emotional expressions, and large-scale political rallies, through the application of a performative framework. This approach often provides insights that may be overlooked by traditional analyses rooted in theatre, drama, and art, which tend to focus on aesthetic or representational aspects. By adopting an expansive view, performance is positioned as a potent tool for understanding complex and wide-ranging processes such as those that are embedded in historical developments, social interactions, and cultural dynamics. This perspective underscores the significance of performance not merely as entertainment or art but as a vital means of interrogating and understanding the underlying mechanisms that shape societal and cultural changes.
Performance Studies actively questions traditional disciplinary boundaries and authority, offering a more fluid, critical view of knowledge production. Shannon Jackson notes that disciplinary labels “should be seen as discursive sites where various agendas, alliances, and anxieties gather,” rather than fixed terms. This self-awareness extends to questioning the “stabilizing, hegemonic role of the Author” and the authority of the “text.” W.B. Worthen, in “Disciplines of the text: sites of performance,” mentions a “romantic sentimentality” that sometimes appears, contrasting “performance’ (transgressive, multiform, and revisionary) with the traditional, repressive, and canonical “domain of the ‘text’.” Performance Studies sees texts and performances as “materially unstable signification registers” that create meaning through intertextual connections, challenging ideas of intention, fidelity, authority, and immediate meaning. Moreover, Performance Studies highlights “radical research” and active engagement with current social and political issues, often prioritizing marginalized voices and unconventional knowledge forms. Dwight Conquergood states that Performance Studies strives to “bridge analysis and action” and to challenge the binary of theory versus practice. It critiques “textualism” or “scriptocentrism,” which devalues the knowledge of “subjugate peoples” by prioritizing written forms over embodied practices. This inclusive approach fosters “cultural equity” and “social justice,” analyzing how performances can reflect or resist globalization and amplify the voices of “dispossessed people.”
Performance Studies offers a versatile and evolving framework for analyzing the world, surpassing traditional humanities approaches. As Diana Taylor notes, by embracing “undefinability and complexity,” the field provides tools to examine culture, question authority, and critically engage with both artistic expression and daily life. Its emphasis on fluidity, interdisciplinary techniques, and the performative nature of human experience fosters a deeper, politically aware understanding of human behaviors, interactions, and knowledge exchange in an interconnected society. Closely interconnected with human behaviors is the work of Judith Butler, Butler’s concept of gender heavily relies on the relationship between performativity and the idea of being “done for others.’ Gender performance is inherently public, socially enforced, and strategically functions to uphold the gender binary by convincing both the individual and society of its validity. Phenomenology provides the essential philosophical basis for Butler’s critique of gender essentialism in feminist theory, offering tools to challenge the idea of a fixed, internal, or natural gender core. This critique is mainly carried out by redefining identity as an ongoing series of “constituting acts” rather than a manifestation of an inherent substance. From a feminist phenomenological perspective, the gendered body should be seen as the “legacy of sedimented acts,” not as an innate essence. This perspective is important because cultural gender distinctions are not innate but are shaped over time by “deeply entrenched or sedimented expectations.” Such understanding enables viewing gender as a “construction that often hides its origins,” which is essential for addressing oppression rooted in the ‘unquestioned reproduction of gender identities.” (Butler). Gender identity is a ‘performative accomplishment driven by social sanction and taboo.’ It is imposed ‘under constraint, daily and incessantly.’ Gender is portrayed as a ‘strategy of survival,’ enacted under ‘duress’ because individuals who ‘fail to perform their gender correctly are often punished.’ (Butler). All this background to say that performativity as we perhaps collectively recognize it, interacts with the work of Butler on nearly every scale, if we rely on the notion that performativity in the modern colloquial is a set of choices or actions taken not out of genuine interest or personal need but rather to garner social credit or validation. This follows Butler’s line of unquestioned reproduction by highlighting the contrast between one’s internal belief systems and their outward expressions. Drawing our attention to whether or not all of it is compulsory after all. This can be seen easily in the current pop culture trend that highlights the social and physical characteristics of the “performative male”, and the gender performance that is occurring there, with the perhaps shallow replication of expressions and interests predominantly championed by women and femmes. Whether this is a conscious choice to replicate a safe identity or an unconscious choice made in order to replicate gender, there is still a heavily compulsory undertone. But then what of the discipline? If all we are is a performance? Is there then a post-performance? Is that even possible?
In the Magic of Objects, Moten interrogates the notion of something having the ability to be post-disciplinary at all, citing the ways in which structure and agency interact, and drawing our attention as readers to Martin’s idea of ‘Critical Moves’, which posits the notion that practices, rather than fixed objects, are central to understanding social phenomena, including race, class, gender, and sexuality. (Moten, 71) This sparked my interest as someone who has aligned most of my research efforts around affect and rhetorical embodiment. It appears that within this context, particularly in Performance Studies, materiality is conceptualized as both a “surplus effect and condition of possibility of materiality as both an active and foundational element in performance and rhetorical practices. This suggests that these fundamental aspects of who we are thus are not abstract but are lived, experienced, and expressed through our bodies. (71). The text advocates for referring to “practices’ rather than ‘objects of knowledge”, emphasizing “the capacity for production over the pre-existing product-object as a fundamental epistemological basis. Randy Martin’s work, as cited, highlights that “practice’ arises as the integrated process of both ‘structure and agency”, where “human activity” is not merely embedded within a static social structure, but both elements are in continuous motion. This “human activity” and ongoing motion inherently involve embodied actions and interactions. (70)
Bishop distinguishes between artists operating in an “activist lineage” (where art is marshaled to effect social change and prioritize legible intentions) and those with closer ties to “avant-garde theater, performance, or architectural theory” who embrace ambiguity, absurdity, and discomfort. Bishop praises artists like Artur Zmijewski and Phil Collins for presenting “uncomfortable, exploitative, or confusing” situations, arguing that “absurdity, eccentricity, doubt, or sheer pleasure” are essential to gaining new perspectives. (Bishop). In considering modern definitions of what is considered perhaps socially ‘performative’ it is interesting for me to look at Bishop’s exploration of Phil Collins’ work. It seems that Claire Bishop would consider Phil Collins’s work, particularly the video installation They Shoot Horses (2004), to be performative primarily because it involves creating a “highly authored situation” that is structured, executed through a deliberate social event, and designed to integrate complex aesthetic and political concerns. Collins’s performative approach is seen as superior because it dismisses the idea of a “correct” ethical decision and the Christian ideal of self-sacrifice, often criticized in collaborative art. Instead, Collins, not unlike Deller and Zmijewski, acts on his desire without being held back by guilt. This differs from artists who are mainly praised for surrendering authorial control or for their modest intentions. But, for me, the interest then lies in the notion that the idea of a body of work being praised for how it can exist without being held back by guilt operates on a performative tilt that champions a lack of sincerity that, perhaps, exists entirely in our moments where we craft something that is genuinely unimpressive? Is the creation of a critique of globalism, done by a British artist, not inherently performative? Suppose performativity as it stands in popular culture now is defined by one’s desire to be impressive, rather than to act out of genuine personal interest. In that case, the notion of Collins’ work thriving due to its self-awareness becomes incredibly interesting to me.
Using the concepts of “ritual” and “play” can illuminate a traditional theatrical event by examining its social role, audience engagement, and perceived impact, as discussed in Santino’s analysis of public displays and performative memorials. Santino describes rituals as “dramatic social enactments that are thought by the participants to have some transformational or confirmatory agency,” deriving their power from an “overarching parahuman authority,” such as a deity, the state, or an institution. The text states that ritual involves Instrumental Efficacy: Rituals, in a stricter sense, are considered “instrumental” because they are “believed to be able to effect change” (Santino). Participants view them as a “conscious means to a desired end and less a doing for its own sake”. For instance, rites of passage are seen as a way to change social status, while healing rituals are thought to have some power to heal. All rituals involve an audience that sees and approves of the changes they bring. However, many official rituals, like weddings, are only open to certain groups, such as family and friends. Some religious rituals are highly private or closed practices, etc.
A traditional theatrical event, such as one held in the Crafton-Preyer Theatre, is a form of “public display,” a “planned-for public occasion” where “accumulated feelings may be channeled into contest, drama, or some other form of display” (Santino). What the text highlights is a significant difference in how audiences interact. It clearly describes a theatre audience as a “passive observer.” By comparing this to the active participation encouraged by public rituals, such as those at the rag well or spontaneous shrines, the text suggests that a theatre audience is more conventional. In a play, the audience typically just watches and receives the performance, rather than taking an active role or contributing to what’s happening on stage, unlike someone who’s actively participating in a ritual (Santino). Suppose a traditional theatrical event is solely for entertainment or aesthetic enjoyment without expecting transformation or societal validation. In that case, it is more a showcase of “theatrical” display than a ritual in its functional sense. However, a traditional theatrical event can lean toward ritual if it encourages active participation from the audience rather than just passive observation. It’s considered to have “transformational or confirmatory power,” aimed at creating change within a community or individual, rather than merely storytelling or providing aesthetic pleasure. Recognizing this helps us see it as a deliberate means to achieve a specific outcome, even if staged. Unlike a standard play, which seeks to evoke emotions or convey a message, a ritualistic theatrical event can tangibly highlight change or reinforce a social or cultural status.
The aestheitcs of a space too are important, The political and aesthetic aspects of performance mainly intersect through two contrasting philosophical views: Bertolt Brecht’s focus on aesthetic duty and Jerzy Grotowski’s emphasis on existential sincerity and anti-commercialism. Brecht’s role is described as a ‘form of aesthetic duty required of the actor.” (Grotowski) This framework establishes a direct link between aesthetic choice and performance requirements. However, Brecht did not offer a practical acting method, raising the question of “How can this be done?” His aesthetic vision focused on the actor maintaining “discursive control over his actions” and employing the Verfremdungseffekt (Alienation Effect). Brecht analyzed technique “from the producer’s perspective, observing the actor,” emphasizing that his political and aesthetic aim was to shape and regulate the external presentation of the performance. In contrast, Grotowski focuses on an aesthetic rooted in the internal, genuine expression of the individual, implicitly criticizing commercialized political or traditional theatre. Grotowski also strongly warns against the aesthetic risk of “publicotropism,” a term used by a Polish actor to describe the danger of making the spectator the “point of orientation” for the actor. (Grotowski) This behavior is condemned as “exhibitionism” and “bad taste,” establishing a powerful aesthetic rejection of mass-market or conventional theatrical relationships. Instead of acting for the audience, the aesthetic must be to act “in confrontation with the spectators, in their presence,” fulfilling an “authentic act” of “extreme yet disciplined sincerity.” This commitment to complete self-revelation—the “act of laying oneself bare”—is Grotowski’s central aesthetic requirement, positioning personal, psychological liberation as the goal. Grotowski stresses that his conscious artistic approach calls for specific non-traditional relationships with the audience (e.g., spectators as “guests” in Dr. Faustus or “onlookers” in The Constant Prince). Therefore, while Brecht enforced an aesthetic of controlled distance (often seen as politically critical), Grotowski’s aesthetic is politically rebellious, emphasizing authenticity and genuinely rejecting theatrical conventions and commercialism.
Alternatively, In Reenactment and Relative Pain, Schnieders’ writing is theoretical, non-linear in many places, and intertextual, and draws from performance studies, feminist theory, psychoanalysis, and poststructuralism. Seemingly, this is done to lend an eye to how reenactment is itself a complex, layered process and not a simple replication of the past, but a messy, affective, embodied, and politically loaded act. Her prose often mimics the experience of reenactment: repetitive, recursive, and uneasy. In this way, style performs the subject matter. Schneider’s writing is visceral and often engages with pain, trauma, and bodily memory—not just as content but as a felt experience. Her use of emotive, sometimes jarring language forces the reader to sit with discomfort, echoing the “relative pain” referenced in the title.
The reader is not merely an outside observer but is actively involved, feeling the nuances of emotional labor as they remember and reenact. The author employs a ghostly and evocative style, emphasizing bodies that no longer exist physically but are resurrected through performance. Her fragmented, poetic tone enhances this haunting atmosphere, creating a sense of presence that is both elusive and tangible.
This style embodies Derrida’s concept of ‘hauntology,’ which suggests the presence of absence, transforming writing into a spectral reenactment. In Schneider’s “Reenactment and Relative Pain,’ style and substance are deeply intertwined. Her complex, recursive, embodied, and affective prose not only serve as a vehicle for her argument but actively enact it. Her writing reflects her themes: history residing in the body, pain migrating through time, and reenactment being inherently political and affective, never neutral.



